The Bidvest Group Limited ANNUAL INTEGRATED REPORT 2012
Download options
Search

 

|  Print  |


Board committees


The board has six Group sub-committees that assist in discharging its responsibilities. These Group committees, listed below, play an important role in enhancing good corporate governance, monitoring and reporting on internal control environments in order to give assurance to the positive performance of the Company:

1. Remuneration committee  
2. Nominations committee  
3. Acquisitions committee  
4. Audit committee  
5. Risk committee  
6. Social and ethics committee (encompassing previous transformation and sustainability committees) 

Each board committee acts according to the annually reviewed and board-approved terms of reference. Copies of the terms of reference, including the board charter, are available at:

QUICK LINK:

http://www.bidvest.com/ar/bidvest_ar2012/009.php.

Board committees may take independent professional advice at the Company’s expense. The committees are subject to annual evaluation by the board on performance and effectiveness. Chairmen of the board committees are required to attend annual general meetings to answer questions raised by shareholders.

Board and sub-committee composition and attendance

The names of the directors who were in office during the period August 27 2011 to August 24 2012 and the details of board meetings, as well as sub-committee membership and attendance is detailed in the directors’ report.

1. Remuneration committee

Our remuneration philosophy promotes the Group’s entrepreneurial culture within a decentralised environment with the aim of achieving sustainable growth within all businesses. Our philosophy emphasises the fundamental value of our people and their role in attaining this objective.

Delivery-specific short-term incentives are viewed as strong drivers of performance.
A significant portion of top management’s reward is variable and is determined by the achievement of realistic profit targets together with an individual’s personal contribution to the growth and development of their immediate business and the wider Group. Long-term incentives align the objectives of management and shareholders for a sustained period.

The committee comprises three independent non-executive directors, Messrs DDB Band (chairman), D Masson and JL Pamensky. The chief executive officer, chief financial officer and other members of senior management may be invited to attend meetings, but may not participate in the vote process of the remuneration committee and recuse themselves from any discussion regarding their performance or remuneration.

The key responsibilities and role of the committee include but are not limited to:
  • Assisting the board to ensure directors and executives are fairly and responsibly remunerated, and disclosure thereof is accurate, complete and transparent
  •   Advising on the remuneration and fees due to non-executive directors
  • Determining any criteria necessary to measure the performance of the chief executive officer, chief financial officer and other executive directors in discharging their functions and responsibilities
  • Considering the appropriateness of early vesting of share-based schemes at the end of employment  
  • Overseeing and recommending the remuneration report to the board for publication

The committee utilises the services of PricewaterhouseCoopers (PWC) as independent advisers on an ad hoc basis. During the year PWC supplied market data and advice on market practice and governance and provided performance analyses on certain conditional share plan performance measures.

The remuneration disclosure is included as part of the directors’ report. Refer full remuneration policy on the website.

QUICK LINK: Remuneration policy

http://www.bidvest.com/ar/bidvest_ar2012/010.php.

 

2. Nominations committee

The role of the committee is to ensure that the board has the appropriate composition to execute its duties effectively. To ensure a rigorous and transparent procedure, any new appointment of a director is considered by the board as a whole, on the recommendation of the nominations committee. The selection process involves considering the existing balance of skills and experience, the balance of executive to non-executive and independent to non-independent directors, racial and gender demographics and the current needs of the organisation as a whole.

For those new appointments, this committee ensures that an induction process is conducted and ongoing training and development of the directors is conducted. The nominations committee also ensures a formal succession plan is developed for the board, chief executive officer and senior management appointments.

The committee comprises three independent non-executive directors, Messrs DDB Band (chairman), JL Pamensky, MC Ramaphosa, Ms T Slabbert and the chief executive officer, Mr B Joffe.

The key responsibilities and role of the committee include but are not limited to:
  • establishment of formal process for appointment of directors 
  • identification of suitable directors in succession planning for senior appointments
  • ongoing training, development and updates of changing requirements in legislation and board roles necessary for the directors to satisfactorily perform their roles
  • performance evaluations of existing directors
  • recommendations for annual re-election of those directors retiring by rotation, annual appointment of audit committee members and other committee memberships as required

In terms of the Company’s memorandum of incorporation the directors who retire by rotation at the forthcoming annual general meeting are Messrs FJ Barnes, LI Jacobs, D Masson, JL Pamensky, MC Ramaphosa, AC Salomon and Ms T Slabbert.

3. Acquisitions committee

The primary purpose of the acquisition committee is to review any significant acquisition for an in-principle decision as to whether the acquisition should be investigated and pursued; as well as to recommend to the board planned acquisitions that have been approved to be in the best interests of the shareholders and to the future growth of the group, or to inform the board of acquisitions that they do not recommend be considered.

The committee is appointed by the board and is made up of the following members Messrs DDB Band (chairman), BL Berson, DE Cleasby, B Joffe, D Masson, JL Pamensky and LP Ralphs, in line with the charter requirements. No formal meetings were held during the period August 27 2011 to August 24 2012; members were however consulted on a number of transactions.

QUICK LINK: Acquisitions committee

http://www.bidvest.com/ar/bidvest_ar2012/011.php.

 

4. Audit committee

The audit committee charter defines the responsibilities of this committee, including but not limited to review of the financial information, assessment of significant statutory and financial risks, scope and function of internal audit, review of internal and external audit reports and the appointment of external auditors.

Group audit committee members are appointed by the board, comprising a minimum of three members and chaired by an independent non-executive director. In terms of the requirements of the Companies Act, the committee reports directly to shareholders.

The committee comprises Messrs NG Payne (chairman), D Masson and JL Pamensky all of whom are independent non-executive directors. Two newly nominated independent non-executive directors being Messrs PC Baloyi and EK Diack have been nominated for appointment to the committee. The chairman of the Company is not a member of the committee. The chairman of the committee reports to the board on the activities and recommendations made by the committee. The financial director, head of internal audit and the external audit partner attend all meetings.

The audit committee’s responsibilities include, but are not limited to the following key areas:
  • to assist the board in discharging its duties relating to the safeguarding of assets, the operation of adequate systems, control and reporting processes, and the preparation of accurate reporting and financial statements in compliance with the applicable legal requirements and accounting standards
  • examining and reviewing the interim report, final profit statement, annual financial statements, the integrated annual report, prospectus or any other documentation to be published by the Company and recommending the adoption of such statements by the board
  • to perform duties assigned to it under the Act and other legislation, including statutory audit committee functions for subsidiary companies
  • evaluating the independence and effectiveness of the external auditors, as well as considering and confirming the external audit fees and making recommendations to the shareholders on the appointment of the external auditors
  • monitoring and supervising the functioning and performance of internal audit
  • reviewing the effectiveness of the Group risk management assessment process, adequacy of internal financial controls (including adequacy of accounting records) and internal control systems
  • considering the appropriateness of the expertise and adequacy of the resources in the Group’s financial function as well as the expertise of senior financial management

Deloitte & Touche are the Group’s lead auditors and Bidvest South Africa divisional auditors, with KPMG auditing the Bidvest Foodservice division. The committee has confirmed the continuing independence and objectivity of the external auditors.

The committee reviewed the combined assurance model which is being developed to ensure that all significant risks identified are adequately addressed by management as well as internal and external assurance providers.

The directors believe that the committee has satisfied its responsibilities under its mandate. Under the sponsorship of the committee’s chairman, a self-evaluation assessment was undertaken during the year and action to address certain issues requiring attention determined.

Based on a review and evaluation of the nature and extent of the documented review of internal financial controls performed by internal audit and the reports prepared by the internal auditors, external auditors, management and other assurance providers, the committee confirms to the board and stakeholders on the effectiveness of the Company’s internal financial controls in the current financial year.

The annual audit committee report disclosure has been included in the report, please refer (here).

QUICK LINK: Audit committee

http://www.bidvest.com/ar/bidvest_ar2012/012.php.


Internal audit

The purpose, authority and responsibility of the internal audit function are defined in a board-approved charter that is consistent with the Institute of Internal Auditors’ definition of internal auditing, and the principles of King III.

A risk-based internal audit methodology has been applied, with input from divisional management and aligned to the organisation’s risk management processes. The three-year rolling internal audit and combined assurance plans are presented to the audit committee for approval. The audit committee considers the objectives and rationale that drives the plan in order to achieve the objectives of internal audit processes. Internal audit plans are reviewed quarterly assessing the ability of the plan to meet the objectives of the audit committee.

Internal audit continued to function independently and objectively throughout the Group in the past year. The internal audit manager within each division, as well as at Group level, reports functionally to the chairman of the respective audit committee. Unrestricted access to members of the audit committee and executives of the organisation is available to the internal audit function. In addition, regular separate meetings took place between internal audit and the chairman of the divisional and Group audit committees during the year under review.

Although not reliant on external auditors for any resource support, the internal audit function, in accordance with the Group’s combined assurance model, continues to liaise with the external auditors, and other assurance providers identified, to maximise efficiencies in assurance coverage on key risks.

Internal audit has focused on the following main areas, as required by King III:
  • objectively assessing the effectiveness of the risk management process, internal financial control (including an assessment of the adequacy of accounting records) and overall operational internal control
  • systematically analysing and evaluating business processes and associated controls
  • evaluating the Company’s governance processes
  • providing a source of information, as appropriate, on instances of fraud, corruption, unethical behaviour and irregularities  

The effectiveness of the Company’s system of internal controls and risk management, as well as the adequacy and availability of skills to address identified risks is assessed by the divisional audit committees and is reported up to the Group audit committee for approval and acceptance.

Based on the work carried out by internal audit during the year under review, controls evaluated were assessed as adequate and effective to provide a reasonable level of assurance that risks are being managed and that Group objectives should be met.

5. Risk committee

The committee assists the board in recognising all material risks to which the Group is exposed and ensuring that the requisite risk management culture, policies and systems are progressively implemented and functioning effectively. Management is accountable to the board for implementing and monitoring the processes of risk management and integrating this into day-to-day activities. Divisionally risk committees and risk registers are established and these are communicated to a Group risk level.

The committee comprises seven directors namely Messrs NG Payne (chairman: an independent non-executive director), D Masson (independent non-executive director) and Ms T Slabbert (non-executive director), and Messrs BL Berson, DE Cleasby, B Joffe and LP Ralphs (executive directors).

We have integrated King III recommendations, and these along with identified Group requirements make up the overall function of the committee being:
  • setting out a formal policy and plan for the management of risks
  • reviewing and assessing the integrity and effectiveness of the risk management process annually
  • considering annually the consolidated risk assessment results and determining trends, common areas of concern, emerging risks, and the most significant risks for reporting to the board
  • monitoring and reviewing changes in stakeholders’ expectations, corporate governance codes and best-practice guidelines relating to risk issues 
  • reviewing and approving the insurance renewal programme
  • assisting the board with activities relating to the governance of information technology

An ongoing enterprise-wide risk assessment process supports the Group philosophy. This ensures risks and opportunities are adequately identified, evaluated and managed at the appropriate level in each division, and that their individual and joint impact on the Group is considered. The internal auditors assist in evaluating the effectiveness of the risk management process and comment on this in their own assessment reports.

QUICK LINK: Risk committee

http://www.bidvest.com/ar/bidvest_ar2012/013.php.

 

Summary of key material issues

Below is a summary of the key material issues identified and actions taken to address these risks and opportunities.
Material issue   Commentary   Risks and opportunities   Page reference  
Remaining competitive in view of the changing world known as the ‘new normal’   As the Group develops new business and expands into new markets and territories, it faces increasingly complex and changing environments. Critical to the success of the Group is the ability of management to ensure their businesses remain relevant and ahead of changing environments   Management needs to anticipate market changes and respond timeously to the environment  
There were a number of businesses where management lacked the ability to change. New appointments have been made with significant confidence in the businesses ability to recover and grow  
24 – 28;
34 – 37;
42 – 45;
52 – 55;
66  
Fostering positive long-term relationships with key suppliers and customers   This remains a cornerstone of the way Bidvest does business   This continues to be recognised as Bidvest’s strength and weakness. Management is constantly challenged on its ability to manage and grow these relationships. This remains a key focus area   34 – 37;
42 – 45;
48 – 49;
66  
Changing legislative environment   Labour, competition, anti-bribery and company legislation is of the higher impact changing environments globally that Bidvest is required to address and respond to   Business is actively addressing these changing requirements in their individual environments throughout the Group. Management is monitoring this progress through the divisional risk committees on an ongoing basis   52 – 55;
56 – 58;
62; 66  
Business continuity plans   Unforeseen events in various businesses throughout the Group have put the BCP’s to the test, successfully to date   Through the ability of businesses to manage and maintain through a period of significant testing, the BCP’s have shown to be not only vital but also, to date, successful. This continues to be an area of management focus   29;
34 – 37  
Appropriate IT systems and support structures   Bidvest has drafted an IT governance framework in order to “support the effective and efficient management of information resources (e.g. people, funding and information) to facilitate the achievement of the organisation’s objectives”   Businesses need to embrace updating and enhancing their IT support structures and environments. It has been recognised that this is one of the highest potential risk processes to be undertaken by a business. Management remains closely involved and is supported by risk and audit committees ensuring adherence to Group frameworks and guidelines   34 – 37;
42 – 45;
52 – 55;
58  
Succession planning   An ongoing area of focus for the long-term success of Bidvest, and all of its businesses   With the recent restructure of the Group, the succession planning of the key roles have been more clearly addressed, and new opportunities for career progression in senior roles have been unlocked, with positive effects on the team   24 – 28;
52 – 55